When Piper has glamoured into little Wyatt, she uses amongst others
telekinesiss. How comes that Piper has this power? She only glamoured to
look like Wyatt.
How does Haas know which powers Wyatt has or how
powerful he actually is?
Malice in Wonderland
When Haas and his demons are in Magic School why do they throw energy
balls around? What's there to vanquish?
When we see the article clippings only the first
paragraph is about missing teens but the subsequent paragraphs is about
some sort of property tax dispute.
How can Dex rent out the garret on the top floor of the building if the
building only has two floors, the second occupied by The Bay Mirror?
The room in the police station is actually the set of The Bay Mirror.
Why did Leo call Piper when Wyatt could orb them both inside with the
blink of an eye?
In one scene Phoebe is holding "Sex & the City: The Complete
Series" but the complete series DVD
set hadn't been released yet.
What happened to Billie's
sunglasses when she fell? Her wig slid off and Paige picked it up but her
sunglasses seemed to disappear.
Billie's wig didn't fall off
when she was doing cartwheels and flips in the air, so why would it easily
fall off when Paige punched her and knocked her to the ground?
Since Utopia has been
prevented why should Phoebe's premonition of a daughter come true?
How could Paige who filled out
her application just few minutes ago, appear in full - and perfectly
fitting - police uniform in the academy.
8x03 Run, Piper, run
Why wouldn't the fall from the penthouse killed that girl? When Piper
unfroze her, she should have hit the mattress with full force.
Why does Maya never seemed to be bothered that Piper was her identical
Silly storyline - why was Phoebe so concerned about Dex's artwork but not
about the impacts of a major earthquake on the whole city?
Where did they get a regulation jail jumpsuit in which to dress Maya when
they switched her with Piper?
If the former owners of the "manor" are dead, where did the
fresh-from-out-of-town cousins meet so many moms to have a play date?
Since when does the ADA get to have a murder suspect that he used to date
released into his custody without a judge's signature?
It is not very smart of Piper to go and answer the door still looking like
the woman who is wanted for murder.
How did Billie learn about the previous adventures of the Charmed Ones? As
far as we could see the BoS is not a diary where The Charmed Ones write
down their adventures.
Has Piper copied Maya's finger prints as well? or DNA?
Why should Nance stick to his confession? And apart from that a forced
confession does not prove anything in court.
8x04 Desperate housewitches
Paige asks Phoebe how they destroyed the Source the last
time? She was there the last time - why does she have to ask?
Phoebe and the writers confuse "astronomy" with "astrology" in the opening
sequence - Phoebe is using astrology (the Zodiac and it's influence) but
refers to it as "astronomy" (the study of the stars).
In Phoebe's vision her nephews were about eight and ten years old, so she
is not due for at least seven more years - why the rush in conceiving a
When Piper returns to find the manor empty, where exactly is baby Chris?
When Billie hits the two demons in Magic School, did she kill them
off-screen? Because leaving demons who are able to shimmer tied somewhere
However, since demons who are vanquished so far have taken their clothes
with them did Biliie strip the demons before vanquishing them?
Billie: "The Halli-whos?"
The most pathetic dodge imaginable since, she's almost living in their
Why getting the key from beneath the porch's welcome mat and unlatching
the front door when it hasn't been locked since the first season?
Shouldn't Dex - now being part of the family - be able to see them as they
Paige leaves her new acquaintance in P3's office where obviously the whole
earnings of the night are stored.
Paige's scrying lands on the map coordinates of Union and Fillmore Streets
in Pacific Heights which later is supposed to be the coordinates of the
Manor, which as we all know is on Prescott Street.
The Department of Homeland Security's San Francisco field office official
seal is wrong.
When Bille comes knocking on Julie's
door when she is together with Dex, Billie says the name Phoebe and not
Julie, which means that if Phoebe could hear it, then most certainly Dex
could hear it too.
8x06 Kill Billie: Vol. I
Paige leads the visitors up to the attic not taking care of the Book of
Kaley misreads the second part of the memory spell
twice in a row by omitting
the second "my".
Why does the demon in woman form wear flip-flops in San Francisco in
"A false positive" pregnancy test is not possible, because home
pregnancy tests are designed in such a way as to allow for false negatives
When Leo and Piper are having their spat in the bedroom
after Leo's fight at Wyatt's
preschool, the bruise on his cheek seems to disappear.
8x07 The lost picture show
What use is it to flip the sign to "closed" when the door is of frosted
Why did Sam put the injured and unconscious J.D. onto the wicker seat,
which has got to be the most uncomfortable place possible for the poor
Cigarettes don't set off smoke detectors.
S. Francisco has banned Segway scooters from their sidewalks three years
How did J.D. know where to look for his father?
Why would Vaklav proposes a trade: Sam for J.D.? He has nothing to win
When Vaklav appears in the attic he obviously found time to place his
camera down carefully on the table in the middle of the room first.
Battle of the hexes
"There's no wrath like a woman scorned"
They screwed up the phrase which actually goes "Hell hath no fury like a
At what university would that students be accepted to take cell phone
calls in class? Not only would the mere ringing of a cellphone get you the
shittiest look from your professor, taking the call, while in class would
get you thrown out immediately.
Hippolyta was not a "greek queen"
If the belt can not be used by evil why should Tai be interesting in
"bringing the belt back".
In the book the demons find at Magic School, Hippolyta is misspelled "Hippolytal"
The spell they used to call for Billie is actually a spell to call for a
Despite being adviced to not corrupt
evidences Billie removes her gloves to pick up the belt.
Witches and demons are different species? Well, has Leo forgotten about
Phoebe and Cole?
If Phoebe could conceive from a demon witches can easily be infected by
virus etc. from demons and vice versa.
Why do they need to infect themselves? Why not simply scrying. Paige could
find Ramone's father with just a photography.
And why must all three be infected?
How could they prepare an antidote in about five minutes and no knowledge
of molecular biology and no pharmaceutical equipment?
Why did Piper so willingly blow up Billie? She couldn't know that it
wouldn't kill Billie.
When Leo was orbed into Burke's cave to
become an ice-man he had the shirt and clothes he ad before the accident -
minus scratches and blood. Wasn't he supposed to be post-op, wearing a
hospital shirt or something?
Where is the garage that's shown for the first time? It has never before
Mr. and Mrs. Witch
A homeless guy pushes a cart full of his worldly
possessions in front of a subway station.
San Francisco does not have subway stations.
It's either the underground MUNI or the BART, but neither of them is
called the subway.
While they all seem to have food on their plates, yet the beautifully
browned prop chicken is sitting there all uncarved and untouched.
The Jenkins are quite rude - they eat someone else's food, they don't hold
up their side of the conversation like any good guest should, they insult
one of their hosts, and they fight with their daughter in front of those
Why is Billie using the word "assassins" for her parents?
Cold-hearted robots/androids/freaks, would fit, even cold-hearted snakes
It does not make sense.
The sisters used the "call for a lost witch" spell to summon Billie's
parents, and while this may work with Billie's mother, it wouldn't with
her father since he is not magical. Plus since
scrying isn't working either (as stated per Paige, although it has been
done successfully before) there would be no way to "call" him.
When the frozen bullet was removed, the trail behind it disappeared
inexplicably as well.
It is once again stated, by Paige this time, that one cannot scry for
non-magical beings, though it's been done, with success, several times
Payback's a witch
Ratio-wise, the headdress of the toy Indian is much, much larger compared
to the headdress of the live Indian. He should've had a headdress about
twice as big.
Why did Billie not only remove the crystal that traps Rohtul but also turn
her back on him?
When Paige signals to Piper how can she know that Piper is able to watch
the security monitors and is there at the right moment?
It's hard to believe that Savard impales himself on this small piece of
rock and die from that.
"they say imitation is the greatest form of flattery"
That's wrong - the saying goes that imitation is the sincerest form of
Twelve angry Zen
Piper: No buts! I gave the same speech to [Raige] -- this
is not your burden to bear. It's mine.
Actually the coming battle is for all three of the girls not only Piper,
which makes the issue with Leo an issue for them all as well.
The Zodiacs say that transferring the staff before midnight would upset
the balance, but the balance is already upset with Rooster dead and Piper
(a "buffalo"/"ox") holding the staff now.
Piper changes her tire at night and Wyatt that she will soon joining him.
The kids are supposed to be at Marineworld with Victor but when Piper call
it is night - surely the kids are no longer there nor is the Institute
open at all.
The "Eternity" symbol is written on the laundry store's glass window...but
it's written so it faces inward. Anyone outside would see it backward,
making it meaningless.
As established, this episode takes place on January 29, the Chinese New
Year. But in "Payback's A Witch," they celebrated Wyatt's birthday, which
as stated in "The Day the Magic Died" takes place on February
1st or 2nd.
To keep the balance who is replacing Rooster?
8x15 The last temptation of Christy
Paige tells Henry that the boys have powers to protect themselves. At this
point, Wyatt, is the only one shown to have powers and adult Chris never
mentioned when he came into his powers.
It's not likely that Piper agrees to let a traumatised kidnap
victim (especially if she was kidnapped by demons) live in the room next
to her children's room.
Despite having spent the last 15
years locked in a demon dungeon, Christy has lovely highlights in her
hair, perfectly manicured eyebrows, absolutely flawless skin, white teeth,
and a perfect manicure.
8x16 Engaged and confused
Paige mix up left and right when
talking about the energyball that barely missed Henry.
Why did the demons not just shimmer
out before Billie tk's the fireball at them? They had time enough.
In the first half of the episode Candor wear robes with the
pentagram facing up (two points up).
Only in the last scenes the penatgram is facing
8x17 Generation hex
Paige is looking directly at Christy when time stops and the latter talks
with Candor. When time starts up Christy has dropped her fork, is facing
differently, and looks markedly different...but Paige, still looking at
her, doesn't notice the substantial changes which would have occurred
simultaneouly from her point of view.
When Phoebe and Coop are revisiting Phoebe's past lives, they revisit her
season 7 love, Drake. When he leaves the room, Coop speaks aloud to
present Phoebe with no regard to whether past Phoebe will hear him - since
they duck and hide, obviously they are visible to the past people, so
can't they be heard too?
Phoebe was wrong when she brought Cupid to the college campus and said
that that was where she first met Cole. They actually met the day before,
when Phoebe and her sisters stopped Emilio from killing Morris.
Why did Paige bother dragging all of her suitcases down the stairs, when
she was going to orb them away with her anyways?
Christy: It's like Death By Dinner! Do you know how hard it is to
smile when you're nauseous?
Either Christy has a
very low self-esteem or her years among demons had effects on her language
skills. Because the word she should have used is nauseated.
8x19 The Jung and the restless
When the girls
collapsed after being put to sleep by Billie and Christy, Pipers hand was
between her legs but in a shot shown
later on she has it resting on her thigh.
has forgotten about Rick Gittridge (6x17 Hyde
School reunion) protests against killing mortals.
8x20 Gone with the witches
colors on the rainbow (which the leprechauns use to travel) are actually
the wrong way round - the color red is actually on the outermost side of
the rainbow with the violet being on the inside.
Where would Dumain get Grams ring for to jinx Piper?
Where did he get the deadly sin ball?
Why did the sin ball leave Phoebe although she has not done a selfless
Why is the leprechauns spell to call for a rainbow used to make to make
visible what has been hidden?
8x21 Kill Billie: Vol. 2
In one of the scenes
where Paige orbs her sisters and herself away from Billie and Christy, the
sisters begin to orb before Paige has her hands on both of them.
Paige: But then he went nuts, and then it
went into Cole, then he went nuts,
then he turned evil, and we had to vanquish him.
Phoebe is mixing up things here. Cole
went nuts for a time after he was vanquished by the sisters, picked up
demonic powers in the wasteland and was rejected by Phoebe after that.
Why did the Hollow leave the sisters and the
Jenkins? The last time it was released a spell chanted by good and evil
was needed to banish it.
8x22 Forever Charmed
When Patty, Piper and
Leo go to Grams' time, Piper introduces Leo as her "lovely
husband from the future",
to which Grams gives no sign of recognizing him, but Grams already knew
Leo from the Summer of Love shown in the season 6 episode "Witchstock".
Why doesn't she recognize him?