7.01 A call to arms
7x02 The Bare Witch Project
7x03 Cheaper By The Coven
7x05 Styx Feet Under
7x06 Once in a blue moon
7x07 Someone to witch over me
7x08 Charmed confidential
7x09 There's something about
7x10 Witchness protection
7x11 Ordinary witches
7x12 Extreme makeover:
7x14 Carpe Demon
7x15 Show Ghouls
7x16 The seven
7x17 Scry hard
7x18 Little box
7x19 Freaky Phoebe
7x20 Imaginary fiends
7x21 Death becomes
Something wicca this way goes
7x01 A call to arms
When Phoebe finds out that her ghostwriter is a guy she
says "Do you even know a guy advice columist?" What about Spencer Ricks?
In the first scene in the kitchen when Piper comes in, she is wearing
slippers of fur and a little while later when we see a full frontal of
her, she is suddenly wearing flip flops.
The exterior of the newspaper office is now a totally different building
then it was the previous season, even though Phoebe's office is the same
7x02 The Bare
During the scene when the girls have to summon Lady
Godiva again to fix the world, they look through the history book and find
only a very brief mention. However, when they cast the spell, you get a
glimpse of Lady Godiva's picture, when Phoebe had just said they couldn't
find any picture at all.
Conveniently, Godiva speaks pretty much normal 21st century American
English, despite having come from Conventry, England in 1040 or
7x03 Cheaper by the
Paige said the summoning spell like this: "Hear me now, hear my cry,
spirit from the other side, cross now the great divide." but it's supposed
to go like this: "Hear these words, hear this cry, spirit from the other
side, come to me, I summon thee, cross now the great divide."
When Gram goes down, in the low shot you can see the ceiling and...it
isn't. Rather then a ceiling, it's simply a billowing white sheet
stretched over the set.
The sign at the award ceremony says, "San Francisco Bay Area Reader's
Choice Awards." Unless there was only one reader, it should correctly say,
"...Readers' Choice Awards."
When Wyatt orbs out after taking Chris's soother, shouldn't Paige be a
little more worried than she was? Even if he did "probably" orb to his
room, you would think that she would at least check.
When Leslie comes to give Phoebe a
feather pen and they are in the house you see that at one camera angle
that there is a wall directly behind her. When the angle changes she is in
the doorway of the parlor (purple room). This keeps changing. Wow! They
just glide side to side to talk.
How did Agent Brody and Sheridan get to the Pirate's cave? Paige, Piper,
and Phoebe only got there by sensing it with the coin and then orbing
Just before Piper freezes Inspector Sheridan, the Inspector says "Look, if
you think that this is going to get me off ..." then is frozen. When she
get unfrozen, she says "... get me off your tail." She repeats the same
In the last part of Phoebe's "Mission Impossible" break in, she clearly
steps on one of the lasers
Wouldn't it have been simpler to just let Leo orb the Chalice to them?
How did Sheridan recover the blood from Piper's bedroom? Previously she
just walked in and got knocked out right away, then woke up down on the
couch. She never had a chance to get anything in Piper's room, but here
that's where she said she got the blood sample from.
Old Paige's shoes change when the rest of her clothing doesn't. Originally
Paige was wearing high-heeled pumps.
If the parrot was a ghost (as we see at the end when it dissolves with the
pirates) and could only travel at night by fog, then how did it get to the
manor in the daytime?
When we see the sleeping Leo at the end, the book on his chest
appears/disappears/reappears in sequential shots.
When Paige is younger her eyes are brown
but when they show her as an older women her eyes are blue.
7x05 Styx feet under
While Leo pulls away from Artie after examining the hole
in his stomach his hand which can be seen through the hole should have
moved along with him but it can clearly be seen that the hand doesn't pull
Death is not supposed to be seen by mortals, but when the list appears in
his hand so he can give it to Piper, his shadow is cast on the man
standing behind him on the sidewalk.
There are not currently any Army bases in San Francisco, but even if there
were, security would prevent Piper and Piage from driving onto the base.
How can someone kill all their blood relatives? Everyone has at least
thousands of distant relations.
7x06 Once in a blue
When Paige grabs the ice-cream it still has the cover on
and there's no sign of a spoon and Phoebe starts talking to her about
personal gain. In the next frame, while Phoebe is finishing her sentence,
we see a close-up on Paige and the cover is off and she has a spoon filled
with ice-cream. There wasn't enough time (less than a second) for her to
open the cover and pick up the spoon.
It's been shown in the past the Elders can listen in on conversations when
they're not present, so is it really a good idea for the sisters to be
discussing Leo's situation out loud in the kitchen?
Why would the Elders think Leo attacked the new Whitelighter - the guy was
clawed (and presumably bitten). How would that possibly tie to Leo?
When the sisters are at the Magic School, the third Blue Moon rises over
San Francisco outside. It's been established in numerous previous episodes
that wherever the School is, it's in a difficult-to-reach place (possibly
another plane of existence) and not in San Francisco.
In his original appearance, Avatar Alpha stated that the Avatars are
beyond good and evil and that he had approached Cole specifically because
Cole had become powerful enough to join their ranks. Leo is powerful, but
not nearly as powerful as Cole; and the Avatars do not seem to be trying
to recruit Leo so much as convince everyone (including Leo) that he has
become evil. So the question becomes: what is so important about Leo that
the (almost) all-powerful Avatars need him to change sides?
7x07 Someone to witch over me
When Paige and Brody are cutting up herbs and plants
for the potion right before the attack upstairs, they are still in the
process of making the potion. But when they hear the crash and Paige orbs
up she takes a finished bottle of potion. When would she have had time to
cook and bottle the potion?
The burning building at the beginning is shown to be at the corner of Polk
and Gough. These two streets exist in San Francisco, but they run parallel
and do notmeet as shown here.
We see the body of the guy who got hit by the speeding truck and
it's...well, intact. Someone hit that hard by a vehicle moving that fast
would not be in any shape like what we see of the corpse here.
So why do they need a banishing potion for the celerity demon, if Piper
can just blow it up with her power?
Paige (about Agent Brody touching the BoS): If the Book of Shadows
considers him a threat, it'll just zap him.
Since when does the BoS "zap"? It only moves away from
Why does the book say "Written by the Mullen
Brothers and the Halliwell Sisters?" Phoebe was the only Halliwell to
write things down, in less you count Paige who was in the book.
Isn't it intersting how even though Kyle's back is facing the door that
when he is shot back by the crystal cage he veers to the right and goes
through the door?
Ms. Donovan: Lord of the Rings?
Gnome Professor: It's historically inaccurate!
The scene is fun but this quote
is a quite silly. Lord of the Rings is pure fiction why should it be
historically accurate? How could it even be?
7x09 There's something about Leo
I know this isn't new, but how long have Wyatt and Chris had their own
room? Wasn't there this whole big problem in the fifth season about Piper
and Leo not having room for the baby and having to turn their closet into
a nursery? No one has left the house, when did they "magically" add on an
While Piper is frozen, during Leo's talk with the Avatars first time round
(just before he tells her he's an Avatar), Piper's hand position changes
while the camera changes angels.
In the scene where Leo tells Piper he's an Avatar there is a continuance
problem. You can clearly see Piper with here back to the camera, putting
the Orange basket on the table and taking the beetle toe, but when you see
here a second later from the front she is again putting the Orange basket
down and taking the beetle toe.
When the invisible demons are attacking the girls they stay invisible.
When the dye is thrown they are revealed to be seen holding energy balls,
however Piper had just mentioned, not three seconds before, that they have
to become visible to attack. If they have to become visible, why didn't
How the heck did Piper get the big family-sized portrait
of herself, Leo, and the boys on the same day (if not the same afternoon)
as when it was taken? No photo studio develops that quick.
Why does Phoebe hide behind Paige and asks her to do something when they
meet the seer in the manor? Has she lost her martial arts fightings skills
The street Brody and Paige emerge in past NY is the same as in 7x08
"Charmed Confidential" just in color.
The newspaper that confirms the date is the "New York Monitor". However,
for some strange reason, it features The New York Times's "All The News
That's Fit To Print" motto on its upper-left-hand corner.
On the not-stopping cab, there is an ad for "Raiders of the Lost Ark". But
this was released in June 1981 and it's extremely unlikely that there are
still ads on a cab advertising that movie in December.
Why did Phoebe and Ronnie both freeze? Phoebe is still a good with even
without her powers. If not, why did Ronnie freeze then? Wouldn't Phoebe's
powers make him a good witch too?
Little Brody must have been damn clever to solve the Rubik's cube in such
a short time.
Since Brody didn't trust Leo why didn't the girls call for Clyde to send
Brody back as in 4x10 "A Paige from the past"?
7x12 Extreme makeover: world edition
When the avatars discuss the spell with Paige, she is sitting at the desk
wearing a rather modestly zippered pink hoodie, but when the camera cuts
back to her for a reaction to Alpha's speech, the hoodie's disappeared,
and she's clad in the crimson camisole thing they're calling a blouse.
In this episode they act as if all and every demon lives in San Francisco.
When Piper's at the Book, explaining that if they alter the tracking spell
they used to locate the Source, it should point them towards Zankou the
writers have obviously forgotten that the actual tracking spell they used
in 4x13 Charmed and Dangerous worked only because the Source had stolen
How could the demons know what's going on and that they have to blend in
with the sleeping people in S.Francisco.?
Hasn't it been said in 4x16 The fifth Halliwheel
that the girls' powers don't work well in the underworld? How can Piper
almost single-handed vanquish all the demons there then?
The avatars have been introduced as all-powerful, allmighty beings. And
then a simple potion can kill one of them? You can't even kill an upper-lefvel
demon with just a potion (at least not without a piece of his flesh).
Unless the avatars performed a big trick while sending the world to sleep
they killed thousands and thousands of innocents, didn't they? Or would
you want to sit in a plane flying, landing or whatever while the crew
falls asleep? And the tower as well? Or in a train? Or on an operation
table while the surgeons snore in your blood? Or how about driving on a
highway with lets say 180 kmh. Or can I tempt you to fall asleep on a
crossing while in the distance a car is approaching? Or .. or .. or ..
That the avatars didn't care much can be seen when this car gently bumps
into another one.
In the scene in the kitchen Phoebe
lifts an entirely empty crust from the counter and shoves it into the
If the Charmed Ones mean so much
trouble why did the avatar not just remove them like they did with Leo?
Previously astral projection had been presented as something one is either
born with or matures into, and it makes no sense that it is now a skill
anyone with sufficient motivation can master.
Roget says that the deal was made 106 years ago. How could he meassure
time when he was in a time loop?
When Roget shoots Drake he should be dead because if the fire can kill him
as he claimed, so can the bullet that just plowed straight through his
Drake talks about visting the 1890s, but he wasn't in the room to hear
Phoebe when she explained about how they determined that Mike was
possessed by someone from the 1890s, and she never told him once he came
Since the loop was supposed to dissolve when the person holding the other
souls prisoner was no longer present, why doesn't the loop dissolve once
Mike doesn't recover when Roget is freed, even though he should have been
as soon as Roget took over Drake's body. Instead, he only recovers later
when Roget is hauled away by the spirits.
At the end, even though the on-screen band consists of only a pianist and
a trumpet player, the actual music we hear them play has a rather
extensive strings section.
7x16 The seven year
Clyde: "Finally got lucky for once, almost running over a doctor."
Why should he be lucky? Leo was the reason for the accident
Sandra: "Leo was not just someone, Piper. He was an Elder, by his own
It was not Leo's choice to become or be an Elder.
Piper: "Well, maybe you should have thought of that before you decided to
become the source of all things evil."
Cole did not decide it, he was possessed by evil.
Why did Odin bring Leo with him - he should have known that the girls will
try to turn Leo so it was not really a smart move to expose Leo to them.
Phoebe says it's been 3 weeks she is with Drake. However in 7x14 Show
gouls Drake said he has only two more weeks to live.
I am light
I am one too strong to fight,
So go away and leave my sight,
And take with you this endless night.
In the spell to banish the shadow they omitted two Halliwell-specific lines Phoebe saw fit to include when
ridding Cole of the entity in 5x11 The importance of being Phoebe.
7x18 Little box of
Piper and Phoebe both leave the
manor with Hope and they don't even think about the fact that Wyatt and
baby Chris are alone in the house. We already knew Leo and Paige were at
Magic School - who was watching the children? Speculation is perhaps a
magical nanny, but we see nor hear proof of this.
The computers and monitors in Hopes dorm room are not connected to
anything. The one standing behind her as she is on the phone is not even a
computer, just an untouched unused ATX case with all the original
EM-shielding in place instead of any cards or connectors.
When Paige and the husband have to administer CPR to the guy who
eletrocuted himself in the elevator, she tells him to push (compress) the
guy's chest 5 times for every breath. This is in fact, infant or child
CPR. Infant and young child CPR consists of 5 compressions for every 2
breaths, while adult CPR consists of 15 compressions for every two.
Towards the end we see a close-up of Kayta's foot in the underworld,
walking on a stone floor, and the "stone" sinks in, obviously giving away
that not real stone was used.
In the first ten minutes, Paige is sitting on the couch with on hand on
her head. Phoebe gives her a coffee mug and she starts to drink it, still
with one hand on her head, but then the shot changes and both hands are on
If the guardians control possession of the thing, how is mankind ever free
to choose to open it again?
Nina: Pandora's box, a gift the gods gave to Prometheus, one that
contained all of the evils of the world, until Pandora unleashed it on an
Actually the myth tells that the Woman Pandora has been given a box and
been sent to mankind.
Sheridan wonders why P3 is "robbed" in the middle of the day, before it's
Obviously she does not realize that a club as wildly popular as P3 will
have thousands of dollars' worth of last night's receipts sitting in the
back office prior to that day's bank run.
When Piper says "Demons never attack at P3!"
she must have blended out her memory of
Bianca in 6x10 Chriscrossed
Jeremy in 2x01 Witch trial
Devlin and co. in 4x09 Muse to my ears
who have all attacked in P3
When Piper and Phoebe visit the councilman why does Piper not freeze the
place from a distance instead of allowing the security cameras to get
When Imara occupiys Phoebe's body Phoebe stands at the BoS and touches it.
Why does the BoS not shield itself from evil?
Why have they never seen the entry for Vicus when searching the BoS for a
demon who might turn Wyatt in season 6?
Why does Adult Wyatt seem to have an English accent when evil, but when
good, he doesn't? This was also the
case in season 6's Cris Crossed.
Future Wyatt should not have been able to use his powers! We learned in
1x17 That 70's Episode that Prue, Piper, and Phoebe
were not able to use magic because their past selves already existed in
7x21 Death becomes them
When Paige and Joanna are talking at P3, there is a bald man that passes
behind Joanna, walking right by her.
Every time the camera focuses on Joanna (3 times) you see the same bald
man pass her in the same direction
In 3x09 Coyote Piper, the Alchemist demon was able to bring the dead back
to life, or at least make them animate again. So why did the Alchemist in
this episode need Zankou to bring him to life again, if he already has the
power to do so?
In 1x12 The Wendigo, Phoebe knew how to change a tire, and was about to
tell Piper how to do it herself over the phone. So how come in this
episode, she has no knowledge of how to change a tire, or what a tire-iron
Throughout the episode Leo is totally bummed because they have to cancel
Chris' first birthday party in case the
demon attacks, and Piper thinks they can't have one until next year. Why
can't they wait until next week? Why
do they act like that one day is the only time they could ever have Chris'
first birthday part?
Why was Inspector Davidson Phoebe's innocent. It was Prue who had to let
him die in 3x16 Death Takes a Halliwell.
Why does Phoebe call for help instead of trying to help Tim?
In 1x20 Prue's life depended on Phoebe to give her CPR when needed so she
must know what to do.
Paige tells Joanna to just call out for her if she needs help. That is a
bit of a strange advice.
Joanna does not know anything about magic or whitelighters so how likely
is it that in a crisis she will just call Paige's name?
7x22 Something wicca this way goes
In previous episodes when Prue used astral projection, she was unable to
use her powers to move things but in this episode, astral Paige was able
to orb a book into Zankou's path.
The potion/spell to remove a witch's powers was ripped from the book in
"How to Make a Quilt Out of Americans" and yet it is now back in the book
for Zankou to use.
Zankou was unique, because he was the only demon able to sense the Charmed
ones...so how come he could not sense that they was in the manor asleep on
In the basement, Phoebe is wearing heels, but when Zankou throws them into
the debris, she can clearly be seeing wearing tennis shoes.
When Zankou blasted Sheriden with an energy ball that was seen by all the
FBI, why didn't the Cleaners come and take care of it? The Cleaners are
supposed to be neutral, so therefor wouldn't they take care of it, or do
they only cover up good magic exposer.
Zankou can steal a witch's powers with the power-stripping spell...but
Paige, being half-white-lighter, would be partially immune. She could have
orbed herself out at the last second, at least.
In the end, after they all walk away - Who has the book? The sisters
didn't have it on them. Leo didn't have it. Darryl didn't sneak it out of
the house. Is it still in the attic up for grabs by anyone (feds
Zankou realizes that the Charmed ones are only astrals of themselves then
he waits so they will wake up downstaris, walk two floors up to the attic,
get the book, flip through it, check outside of the window and see the
feds suround them and only THEN does he teleport in - Why did he wait so
When the potion to strip a witch's power was used in season 2 it required
that the victim swallow it, throwing it wasn't enough. The potion itself
wasn't enough since they needed to read a spell. In fact, the spell to
appears in this episode at the bottom of the page were the spell was
How can the feds (or whomever) really believe the sisters are dead? There
were no bodies at the basement or anywhere else in the house. And it's
unlikely their bodies were completely disintegrated since the basement
seems relatively intact.
Isn't it a little odd that the sisters would simply send the trolls and
the other magical creatures into the manor to get killed? Are their lives
less valuable than the sister's?
In Season 4, episode "Bite Me" it's revealed that vampires are immune to
witches magic, yet Piper was able to blow up vampire bats in this episode.
Since when is astral projection
something that can be learnt? So far it was a given power.
Glamouring has been part of the
whitelighter powers or it was demonic. How come the girls can now not only
glamour with a finger snip but also change the appearance of others (e.g.