They say Eva wasnt in the attic but
in Phoebes premonition you see her next to Paige
At Teresa's funeral the box of crackers was on top of the bananas, then it
disappears in the next shot of the casket.
When Phoebe takes the gypsy's hands at the beginning of the episode, one
camera angle shows Phoebe's hands on top of the gypsy's, while another
angle shows Phoebe's hands under the gypsy's.
When the Gypsy reads Phoebe's palm she draws lines on Phoebe's hand
however when Phoebe sat down at the table the lines were already visible
on her hand before they had been drawn there.
5x07 Sympathy for the demon
Cole says Barbas can use his power
to become the Source - in the episode "Womb Raider" they established an
aspiring Source also needs the Grimoire, which was hidden away by Leo
beneath the Andes.
If stripped powers need a body to go to after being stripped, how come
Belthazor's powers didnt go anywhere in 4x08 Black as Cole
When Phoebe is hugging Paige after Leo brings her back to life, in the
background Paige's head is on Phoebe's left shoulder facing the camera,
but on the close-up before they stand up, it is on Phoebe's right shoulder
A witch in time
The brief shot we see of Phoebe's
newspaper letter column consists of two-sentence opinions on different
subjects and there's no indication of any letters from readers or
The gangbanger's hand moves noticeably as the extra tries to hold the gun
up and pretend to be "frozen."
When Phoebe runs into the building to see if Miles is still there, we see
and hear that she is wearing black high heeled shoes. (You can see hers
shoes more clearly the second time she runs in) When she comes out and
when her and Piper are running down the sidewalk you can see she know has
on big cream colored boots that look a lot more comfortable.
When future-Piper and present-Piper are sitting in the car, future-Piper
pinches present-Piper and then shows her arm, cause she got a bruise (to
show that they're the same person). Wouldn't the baby heal the bruise
Leo should have been in awful pain the second Paige died, because that
always happens when one of his charges is hurt or killed. Instead, he orbs
up to the attic after Piper calls for him and he's shocked to see two of
the sisters dead.
Why couldn't Paige summon the arrow and the poison from Sam? If she
couldn't touch it all she had to do was get a pair of cleaning gloves from
the kitchen first
In P3, when Piper and Phoebe are talking about nannies, when the camera is
on Piper, the people in the background, dissapear only to reappear in the
When Leo and Piper orb in the kitchen while Cole is impersonating Sam, Leo
has his hand on Piper's upper arm close to her shoulder holding her close
to him, when the camera is behind them and we see Phoebe mixing a potion,
Leo's hand is not in the frame but Piper's right shoulder and arm are.
During the post-credits conversation between Paige and Piper (sorry, not
Phoebe), Paige's black bra-strap pops in and out of view each time the
When Paige and Phoebe are sitting
at the bar at the beginnning their arms change positions between every
The mummy's tomb
During the establishing shot, before Phoebe, Darrel, and Paige go to the
crime scene, there is a drop of water on the camera lense, look carefully.
It is in the bottom right corner.
Piper's hair keeps going from in front of her shoulder to behind while she
is in the attic talking to Leo and Paige about Jeric. Between Leo, Piper
and Paige failing to stop Jeric from taking Phoebe to when they returned
to the manor to try to locate her, Leo's hair appears to have been
trimmed. It has grown out again when he goes to meet Daryl.
Didn't Leo and Piper convert their closet into a nursery earlier this
season? Now it's back to a closet as we see when they change clothes.
5x11 The importance of being
If Cole's apartment was protected by magic, how could he and Kaia go in
and out of it (shimmering or whatever they do) but Leo couldn't? Maybe it
was protected from good magic only, but still, if this is so, how did
Piper's spell get into the apartment (a good spell), and how did Phoebe's
powers get in and out of the apartment (good powers from a good witch)?
controls her powers. It has its upside and its downside. Regarding Cole's
protection, if you'll notice he didn't
The Basement in "Is there a Woogy in the House" is dramatically differnet
than the one we see in seasons 3 and 4, persumebly because they fixed it.
But in this episode the basement is back in its "original" state.
After Phoebe has been knocked unconscious, Cole picks her up and puts her
on the bed. When he goes to pick her up, Phoebe wraps her arms around his
neck, but if she were really unconscious, her arms would have fallen limp
by her side.
While Cole and Kaya are in the Penthouse with Phoebe unconcious on the
floor, Phoebe's face is turned up, or at least sideways. When Cole goes to
pick her up, her face is down towards the floor.
For a bail of $50,000, you'd only have to put up 10% collateral with a
bondsman. It seems nuts to believe that the sisters don't have $5,000 in
collateral - either the Grand Cherokee or Phoebe's recently purchased new
sports car would be more than sufficient.
When Paige has her police photos taken, one shot shows her green vest
thingy on one shoulder while another shot shows it on both shoulders. The
shots are switched between many times in the scene and so it magically
switches more than once.
How convenient that Phoebe immediately remembers the spell to ban the
5x12 Centennial Charmed
sliced off the piece of flesh, why did Cole not simply transform his blood
again as he did in 3x21 "Look who's barking".
Since orbing is a natural part of Paige having nothing to do with the
Power Of Three, why couldn't she orb in the alternate reality. If it was
because she was dead in that reality, then how could she gain restore the
Power Of Three in that reality to vanquish Cole?
On Paige's tombstone, it reads "Paige Matthews. Born 1975. Died 2001." In
Charmed Again (2), Sister Agnes mentions that Paige was born in 1977. BUT
since it's an alternate reality, perhaps Paige could've been born in 1975
instead of 1977.
When Paige appears in the alternate reality in the back room of P3, the
room looks well-kept and almost exactly like it did before in the real
world (just did a little darker). But when Paige opens the door, which
falls of its hinges, the club is a mess. Why was the back room so tidy
while the rest of the club became so rundown?
A pretty strange thing in the alternate reality - if Paige hadn't joined
Phoebe and Piper, then the source should still be alive, and Cole should
still be on the top most wanted list in the underworld. He should be good
When Cole comes home at the beginning of the episode the picture of him
and Peobe is on the left hand side of the table and the box is on the
right hand side. When Phoebe picks up the picture and puts it down on the
table the box is now on the left hand side and she places the picture on
the right hand side.
At the beginning of this episode, Leo and Paige orb to where Piper was
hunting that demon guy, he kneels down at that man and Piper appears, she
then freezes him, the scene goes to Piper and back at the demon who is now
When Cole knocked Paige out the window, why didn't she just orb out of the
air instead of falling into the water? She's done it before when Phoebe's
unborn evil baby knocked her out the attick window and she orbed back in.
Why is Cole finally vanquished? Like Piper said, they thought they'd
vanquished him twice before. Why didn't he go to the plain where
vanquished demons go, like he did before?
How could Paige be born in 1975? In that 70's episode Patty was pregnant
with phoebe in 1975.
When the piece of ceiling falls on
Piper, in the close-ups she is covered in plaster debris with a big piece
sitting on top of her head. In the long-shot there is little dust and
debris and no plaster chunk on her head.
A legal wedding usually requires the couple, an official and a witness.
When Leo takes Jessica back to the Church and leaves with Paige, it is
still day. When they get back to the manor it is night. Why did it take
several hours to orb across town?
At the end when Leo knocks the dish off of the bar, Piper says that it's
ok and they'll clean it up later. That would never happen - anyone could
slip on one of the peanuts or cut themselves on the broken dish. It would
be a lawsuit waiting to happen.
During Phoebe's photo shoot, she takes off her dress and then the
photographer tells someone to turn the fans on. In the shot immediately
before he mentions the fans, Phoebe's hair is already blowing in the wind.
Not a blooper but - although it was
night when Piper was finished "cleaning" the house, wouldn't someone
notice that suddenly there is a house missing in Prescott St.?
When Phoebe and Paige were at the campgrounds, Paige was knocked to the
side and then the sandman and Phoebe were knocked down. Phoebe got dusted
too much, the chainsaw murderer came to life, and Paige rolled in to orb
them out. She rolled. in from the right, but before, she was knocked to
the left side.
How come the lower demon killed the upper demon so fast?
After dealing with their dreams, when the Tracer Demon shows up Piper
turns to blow him up, you can see she is clearly not pregnant, even
thought she was a second ago.
When Paige goes into her dreams the second time, she has her srapon her
shoulders, then when she bends down to pick up the baby, her strapis lower
- on her arm, then when she holds the baby, the strap is back to where it
5x15 Special delivery
In 2x12 "Awakened," Piper clearly
states that she hates hospitals, so why has she suddenly changed her mind?
She is now intent on having the baby on the hospital, although everyone
else wants the birth to occur at home.
When Paige orbs into Piper and Leo's bedroom the ruffles of her shirt are
on the right side, but when her and Phoebe come downstairs to meet Piper
they are on the left.
As recently as two episodes ago 5x13 Obsessions we saw that the house had
a wall of trees behind the house. In this episode the same view is a clear
shot of the city.
The Aurora Borealis is only _barely_ visible in Northern California.
Additionally, the lights of San Francisco (a very large, very well lit up
city), Oakland (ditto), and the rest of the greater SF Bay Area are so
bright, they obscure most celestial objects and events. The girls would
have had to travel north (probably to Sonoma County at minimum) if they
wanted to see something in the night sky.
The elastic holding the horn on the "unicorn" is clearly visible in most
scenes featuring the animal.
When Stanley begins to strangle Paige, you can tell it's not her - it is
clearly a male stunt-double.
In the bar scene before the fight broke out. The sorcerer introduced the
witches to a wizard. I thought wizards were extinct after the last one
died in 4x19 "We're Off to See the Wizard"
5x16 Baby's first demon
Victor was listed on the family tree as "Victor Jones" instead of "Victor
Although Patty and Grams both have their full first name on the family
tree, Patricia and Penelope, respectively, Prue is listed on the tree as
just "Prue" not "Prudence".
The baby is clearly a doll, when the hawker first attacks, and Piper picks
it up, it's quite stiff and has the cape thingy over his head, but when
the camera goes for the baby-close-up he's quite more vivid and his head
When the demon who is trying to sell his "perimi-o-tonic" which is
supposed to increase your strength, yet it also changed his face and skin
The Transamerica Building is oddly visible out the attic window (scene
after Seamus' death). We seem to be a couple streets over (on Battery or
Kearny, for example; I'm not positive which direction we're facing, but it
seems we're looking mostly perpendicular to Montgomery Avenue). The attic
also appears to be at equal elevation with (give or take) the 25th story
of the pyramid. I cannot imagine where this perspective might be possible
given San Francisco's geography and the fact that the girls live in a
single-family dwelling on a flat residential street.
Since when has Phoebe been able to speak in her premonitions? Now she says
the chant to summon the rainbow while in her premonition.
In general, some parts of some of
the scenes from the past were clipped for time, so some of the "memories"
When Kit runs into the bathroom while Piper and Leo are showering, Phoebe
runs after her to bring her out, but not only does she come out without
her, but she also closes the door of the bathroom, trapping Kit inside.
When Paige is talking to Katrina, the necklace that she was wearing was
not around her neck, but when she orbs in to help Phoebe in the fight, her
necklace is back but her jacket is not (she left it behind).
In the flashback of Piper and Leo's shower scene, why was the door
partially open? When the original episode aired this, the door was
Why is Leo remembering Piper's dance from "Coyote Piper" as part of their
good times?!? Didn't "she" knock him out concious a little earlier? And
even if he remembers it from Piper due to the spell, why is that a happy
time for him?
The American flag we see in the kitchen on the refrigerator during the
bridal party sequence (as Paige is making her potion) wasn't there
originally two years ago.
Paige: Evil? You were blonde.
Why is Paige surprised? Pheobe's hair colour is "blonde" during the first
episodes of season 4 when Paige met her. This is clearly evident
especially in the episode 4x04 "Enter the Demon"
Todd Duffey (the satyr at the
beginning) seems totally unable to lip sync along with the music - he's
all over the place with his mouth.
As far as I could tell, the nymphs cavorted barefoot. When they
transformed Paige into one of them, she was dancing in beige, wedge-heel
sandals instead of being barefoot. Then when they were following Tull
through the woods, she had on dark-colored sandals. Beyond the shoe change
goof, Paige shouldn't have had footwear.
5x20 Sense and sense ability
When Piper freed Leo from water
tank with her powers. When he was freed, his whole body was wet. But when
he stands up again, his back was dry, but his front were wet.
At the end before Rose performs, Phoebe is drinking tea. Watch the tea bag
string. It moves between shots.
In the shots with all three of them (Piper, Wyatt and the Crone) Wyatt's
head is sticking out of his baby blanket. But in the shots of just Piper
and Wyatt, the blanket is covering the back off his hea
5x21 Necromancing the stone
When Grams starts her man bashing rant, Leo points out she was married 4
times, but in 4x12 "Lost and Bound," Phoebe stated Grams had been married
6 times. In the 3x02 "Magic hour," Phoebe says that Grams was married 4
times. They should make up their minds.
Why exactly did Piper called for Paige and the begining? All Paige did was
read a spell. You'd think Piper could do that on her own.
5x22 Oh my goddess, part 1
Piper and Phoebe talk about getting
air conditioning for the manor. But in 3x05 "Sight Unseen" Cole turned on
the air conditioning to help flush out the demon Troxa.
Paige's hair doo is different when she's a statue
Why did the dwarf call himself a dwarf when in 5x03 "Happily Ever After",
Leo said that they pefer to be called "Little People"?
5x23 Oh my goddess, part 2
In 3x01 "The honeymoon's over",
Piper and Leo come back from wherever the Elders live, and although only a
day went by there, a month went by on Earth. How come when Leo, Chris,
Piper, and the Titans are up there for so long, the same amount of time
seems to go by on Earth?
The Elders decision to leave Chris were he is doesnt seem to make much
sense. Wouldn't they realize that leaving someone from the future in the
past could mess up the timeline even further?